COURTESY HT JAN 15

Will stand with farmers’: Mann quits SC’s panel
Protesting farm unions have already declared 4-member committee as biased in favour of laws

Zia Haq

Zia.haq@htlive.com

New Delhi : Bhupinder Singh Mann, a key farm union leader appointed by the Supreme Court to a panel it formed to scrutinise three contentious farms laws has declined to be on it, citing the “interests” of farmers.

Mann, a former MP and the national president of the Bharatiya Kisan Union, a farm union, said he was “recusing” himself from a committee of four set up by the Supreme Court to look into farmers’ grievances over the laws.

On January 12, the court stayed the laws that have prompted tens of thousands of farmers to stage a protest on the borders of Delhi. It also set up a committee to start a dialogue with protesting farmers, naming economists Ashok Kumar Gulati and PK Joshi as well as farm union leaders Anil Ghanwat and Mann as members.

The panel formed by the Supreme Court attracted public criticism because all four members had either endorsed the farm laws or suggested improvements in them previously. Protesting farm unions said such a committee was already biased in favour of the legislation.

“As a farmer myself and a union leader, in view of the prevailing sentiments and apprehensions amongst the farmers and public in general, I am ready to sacrifice any position offered or given to me so as not to compromise the interests of Punjab and the farmers of the country,” Mann said in a press statement. The Supreme Court had said on Monday that the panel must meet within 10 days.

Mann is the chairman of the All India Kisan Coordination Committee, a platform of farm unions that has supported the farm laws.

Mann met Union farm minister Narendra Singh Tomar in December, urging him not to repeal the laws. This pit him against hundreds of other farm unions demanding a repeal.

An official of the agriculture ministry declined to comment on Mann’s move, saying this was a Supreme Court-monitored process. Farm unions protesting the laws to open up agricultural markets said they were indifferent to Mann’s decision.

“Our stand is we will not take part in any consultations by the court-appointed committee because our only demand is the repeal of the laws,” said Darshan Pal, a senior member of the Sanyukt Kisan Morcha, the organisation leading the farmers’ protests. Another farmer leader, Abhimanyu Kohar, told news agency PTI that government knows the court cannot repeal the laws and that it should stop playing with the sentiments of farmers who have been camping at several Delhi borders since last November.

“This is a good thing that Mann has recused himself. Forming a committee is not a solution. The new farm laws have been enacted by Parliament and the court cannot do much. The government knows this that’s why we are asking the government to repeal these three laws,” PTI quoted Kohar as saying.

Bhartiya Kisan Union leader Rakesh Tikait also welcomed Mann’s decision.