Wednesday, August 05, 2020
Follow us on
जम्मू कश्मीर के कुलगाम में संदिग्ध आतंकियों ने की सरपंच की हत्याबेरूत ब्लास्ट पर लेबनान के पीएम बोले, 2750 टन अमोनियम नाइट्रेट का हुआ विस्फोटसुशांत सिंह आत्महत्या केसः रिया चक्रवर्ती की याचिका पर SC में आज हो सकती है सुनवाईलेबनान ब्लास्ट से प्रधानमंत्री कार्यालय को भी पहुंचा है नुकसानराजस्थानः बसपा विधायकों के कांग्रेस में विलय के मामले में आज सुनवाई करेगा HCअयोध्या: राम मंदिर का भूमिपूजन कार्यक्रम आज, पीएम मोदी होंगे शामिलधमाके से दहल उठी लेबनान की राजधानी बेरूत, 78 की मौत, सैकड़ों घायल,एमरजेंसी लागूबिहार: खगड़िया में यात्रियों से भरी एक नाव गंडक नदी में डूबी, कई लापता

TOI EDIT-North-east Protests Stop and think. Citizenship (Amendment) Bill will create more problems than it solves

December 11, 2019 06:08 AM


North-east Protests
Stop and think. Citizenship (Amendment) Bill will create more problems than it solves
Following a fierce debate in the Lok Sabha, the Citizenship (Amendment) Bill (CAB) was passed in the lower House of Parliament with a comfortable margin. BJP’s numbers were further shored up by the likes of recent ally-turned-rival Shiv Sena and NDA constituent JD(U), which has generally sought to keep a distance from the more controversial themes of BJP's agenda. There is a strong possibility of the legislation going through Rajya Sabha, too, on Wednesday. But the real test awaits it in Supreme Court where it is set to be challenged on the ground that it is at odds with constitutional provisions – in particular, Articles 14 and 15, which forbid the state from discrimination on religious and other grounds. Union home minister Amit Shah argued that the bill meets the "reasonable classification" threshold of exceptions. But whether the legislation passes judicial muster remains to be seen.

The government will also have to answer why the bill does not cover Tamil refugees from Sri Lanka. Shah said that CAB wasn’t against any community and that it would not have been necessary had Congress not accepted Partition on the basis of religion. This argument may not hold weight as India was not created on the basis of religion, only Pakistan was. That, in fact, is the differentiator between India and Pakistan, and arguably the reason India is much more of a success story than Pakistan is. India is also held in higher regard among the comity of modern nations for that reason.

Predictably, CAB’s contravention of Assam Accord provisions has led to a severe reaction in north-east states, with student bodies and indigenous groups agitating. Yesterday saw widespread protests in Assam; normal life was also affected in parts of Arunachal Pradesh, Tripura and Meghalaya by a bandh called across the north-east. Even states with the Inner Line Permit system (ILP) – Nagaland, Mizoram and Arunachal – are apprehensive that the bill will see an influx of outsiders.

In fact, CAB’s exemptions for ILP states – Manipur is now one of them – and Sixth Schedule areas could create more complications. Identifying outsiders versus locals is a vexed issue in states like Manipur. CAB appears to being pushed through without adequate thought of social, political, constitutional and foreign policy consequences. The Rajya Sabha, acting as India’s House of Elders, may want to give it a hard look

Have something to say? Post your comment