Saturday, July 20, 2019
Follow us on
BREAKING NEWS
राष्ट्रपति ने मध्यप्रदेश, बिहार,उत्तरप्रदेश, पश्चिमी बंगाल,त्रिपुरा और नागालैंड के नए राज्यपाल नियुक्त किएजम्मू-कश्मीर: पुंछ में पाकिस्‍तान की ओर से सीजफायर उल्‍लंघन, गोलीबारी में एक नागरिक घायलगाजियाबाद: सेल्स टैक्स की तीसरी मंजिल में लगी भयंकर आग, खंड 15 व 16 के रिकॉर्ड जलेसोनभद्र संग्राम: कांग्रेस नेताओं को वाराणसी एयरपोर्ट पर हिरासत में लिया गयाएमएस धोनी ने BCCI से कहा- अगले दो महीने के लिए पैरा मिलिट्री में शामिल हो रहा हूं HARYANA CM PRESS CONFERENCE AT 4 P.M.हरियाणा हायर एजुकेशन ने नव नियुक्त 224 असिस्टेंट प्रोफेसर के पोस्टिंग ऑर्डर्स जारी किए है पंजाब के मुख्यमंत्री कैप्टन अमरिंदर सिंह ने नवजोत सिंह सिद्धू के राज्य मंत्री के पद से इस्तीफा स्वीकार कर लिया
 
Editorial

ET EDIT-When the Forward Wish to be Backward Dynamic economy is the cure for quota demands

July 13, 2019 06:18 AM

COURTESY ET EDIT JULY 13

When the Forward Wish to be Backward
Dynamic economy is the cure for quota demands
On Friday, a Supreme Court bench refused to stay a Bombay High Court order that upheld classification by the government of Marathas as a ‘socially and economically backward’ community. The high court had recommended 12-13% quotas for Marathas in the state sector. This is ridiculous. For 400 years, Marathas have been one of the most powerful communities in west-central India: landed, warlike, wealthy and politically powerful. Shivaji forged the Maratha identity in the 17th century, but the community is also powerful outside Maharashtra, including the Holkars of Indore, Scindias of Gwalior and Gaekwads of Baroda. They occupy 20% of all government jobs in Maharashtra, dominate the sugar sector, cooperative banking and private education. Since 1960, 11 of 18 chief ministers, including Yashwantrao Chavan, Vilasrao Deshmukh and the redoubtable Sharad Pawar, have been Maratha. Most have held important portfolios at the Centre.

The high court judgment is a rehash of a report, published in November 2018, by a commission headed by M G Gaikwad. This report is a hodgepodge, conflating economic with social status, digging out obscure references to ‘prove’ Marathas originate from shudras in the varna system. However, early Maratha chronicles cite kshatriya origins and the Mandal Commission, correctly, classified them as a ‘forward caste’.


The Maratha demand for quotas follows similar demands from wealthy, economically and geographically mobile patidars in Gujarat, and the BJP government’s promise to grant Scheduled Tribe (ST) and Other Backward Class (OBC) status to six Assamese ethnic groups. This includes Ahoms, who ruled the region from 1228 to 1826, and continue to be powerful. That privileged classes now want quotas reflects mismatch between societal aspirations and opportunities for social mobility, particularly via diversified non-farm jobs. The solution is not to reserve higher proportions of a stagnant state sector, but to make sure education and employment opportunities grow faster than the potential workforce, and dispersed access to both.

 

Have something to say? Post your comment