Friday, March 29, 2024
Follow us on
BREAKING NEWS
लाल कृष्ण आडवाणी को भारत रत्न 31 मार्च को दिया जायेगा,आडवाणी को उनके पृथ्वीराज रोड निवास पर 1130 बजे भारत रत्न से नवाजा जाएगा, पीएम मोदी सहित कई वरिष्ठ मंत्री और बीजेपी के आला नेता भी रहेंगे उस अवसर पर मौजूदपटना से अहमदाबाद जा रही इंडिगो फ्लाइट मेडिकल इमरजेंसी के कारण इंदौर में उतरीमुख्तार का शव पोस्टमॉर्टम हाउस से निकला, गाजीपुर लेकर जा रही पुलिसजिला नूंह की टीम को मिली बड़ी सफलता, 9336 अवैध शराब की बोतलों को ले जाते हुए ट्रक को किया काबूटीबी को हराने के लिए सरकार-समाज का साझा प्रयास जरूरी : डॉ. सुनील कुमारगुरुग्राम स्थित श्रवण एवं वाणी निशक्त जन कल्याण केन्द्र में बने डिजिटल साइन लैंगुएज लैब में बधिर मतदाताओं के लिए संकेत भाषा में तैयार हुआ वीडियोचुनाव का पर्व-देश का गर्व में प्रत्येक मतदाता दे अपना योगदान – अनुराग अग्रवालसीएम योगी आज शामली, मुजफ्फरनगर और सहारनपुर में करेंगे जनसभा
Dharam Karam

WHO IS A HINDU? Vedanta and LGBTIQ

July 22, 2018 06:14 AM

WHO IS A HINDU?
Vedanta and LGBTIQ
A fortnightly column that filters the voices on all sides
A selective understanding of the faith by those who control social discourse is the tragedy of Hinduism
BY DEVDUTT PATTANAIK

Dhol, gavar, shudra, pashu, nari; sakal tadan ke adhikari.’ (‘Drums, uneducated people, ‘low’ castes, animals, and women deserve a beating to straighten up and get their act together.’) This quote from the 16th century Ramcharitmanas of Goswami Tulsidas is hurled repeatedly at anyone saying anything good about Hinduism to prove that it is patriarchal, misogynistic and casteist. But few quote the following lines, from the same text: ‘Nar, napunsak, nari, va jiva, chara-char koi; sarva bhav bhaj kapat taji, mohe param priya soi.’ (‘Men, queers, women, even plants and animals, all living creatures who abandon malice and approach me with affection are dear to me.’) Ramcharitmanas is an Awadhi text that retells the story of Ram and establishes him as God. It plays a key role in the bhakti traditions of North India. Most North Indians assume it is the fundamental text of Hinduism annoying Hindus from West, East, and South India who have their own sacred texts in their own local languages. But we do live in times where Hindi calls the political shots and all other regional languages have to surrender to its privileged position.

Be that as it may, it is interesting that many young educated people who have never really been exposed to Tulsidas’ magnum opus know the first verse that projects Hinduism in a poor light. They are not exposed to the second verse. Is that deliberate?


The first verse contains the words of Varuna, the sea-god, who is mocked by Ram, to whom the verse is addressed. The second verse is spoken by Ram himself to the wise crow Kakabhusandi. The lesser god (deva) speaks of hierarchy and oppression, the greater God (bhagavan) speaks of equality and diversity, acknowledging even the queer. Which verse defines Hinduism?

Most curiously, both Leftists and Rightists insist that the verse that celebrates hierarchy defines Hinduism — Leftists criticise this, Rightists defend it. Neither really wants to acknowledge the wisdom of Hinduism, for that will take the wind out of each other’s politics. So neither quotes, or is even aware of, the latter verse. This selective understanding of the faith by elites as well as goons, on both sides, who control social discourse is the tragedy of Hinduism.

I keep hearing celibate and celebrity male Hindu monks and mystics and selfproclaimed media-endorsed Hindu leaders insisting that homosexuality is not part of Hinduism, only transgender people are. Of course, that does not mean they will give transgender people any real power or resources. It is just lip-service.

They will say that Vedanta does not support homosexuality. When they say this, they are turning Hinduism into an Abrahamic faith like Islam, Christianity and Judaism where God’s permission is sought to be true to one’s feelings. The Hindu leader is thus cleverly positioning himself as God’s messenger, which is not a Hindu concept at all.

Hinduism celebrates nature (prakriti) and all that it offers: nara (male), napunsak (queer), nari (women), plants and animals. In nature, all kinds of sexuality exists. As per botanists, most plants have male and female organs simultaneously. As per zoologists, hundred species of animals, in different contexts, display samesex behaviour, and same-sex parenting. As per psychiatrists, human sexuality is complex and there is tension between biological urges and social values. Human society (sanskriti) struggles to accommodate this diversity, and, like a farmer who controls the farm and declares certain plants to be weeds, humans filter nature’s diversity as per their whims and wisdom. In a patriarchal society, the human gardener will value men over women, priests over sweepers, queers over heterosexuals. It will rather curiously consider celibacy to be holy, and not unnatural (though it is, as per many scientists). In wisdom, mind is expanded, and all options are accommodated — heterosexual, homosexual, and room is made for men, women, transgenders and intersex, celibate and polyamorous, single parent as well as multi-parent and same-sex-parent family.

As the nun Sulabha tells Janaka in the Mahabharata, ‘The resident of the body (dehi) has no gender. The body (deha) has many genders and desires.’ The hermit rejects the body and wealth and seeks dehi. The householder finds the wisdom to celebrate the diverse manifestation of deha as an expression of dehi. Deha is an outcome of karma over which we have no control. Dehi is a witness observing how, in ignorance (avidya), we get agitated and seek control over diversity and establish hierarchy.

Today we have celibate monks who love money (but of course have not a penny ‘officially’ in their name), telling young boys and girls and queers and their parents how they should have sex, and with whom. They are giving themselves power, and establishing hierarchy, which is not the wisdom of Vedanta.

Ancient India has over 50 words for non-normative queer sex, gender and sexualities in Sanskrit and Prakrit. One of them is napunsaka! They are all jiva-atma (individual souls) who are dear to Ram who embodies param-atma (cosmic soul). That matters more than the opinions and prescriptions of politicians, activists, and babas

Have something to say? Post your comment
 
More Dharam Karam News
दूरदर्शन पर रामलला का होगा दिव्य दर्शन, हर रोज सुबह 6.30 बजे नित्य आरती का होगा लाइव प्रसारण
श्री गुरु रविदास जयंती पर विशेष
अयोध्या में दर्शन की व्यवस्था खुद देख रहे डीजी प्रशांत कुमार अयोध्या में रामलला के दर्शन को उमड़ा जनसैलाब
गर्भगृह में रामलला की प्राण प्रतिष्ठा
प्राण प्रतिष्ठा से पहले बोले CM योगी- सदियों का संकल्प पूर्ण हुआ अयोध्या: आरती के समय 30 कलाकार अलग-अलग भारतीय वाद्य यंत्रों का वादन करेंगे आज बंद हो जाएंगे बद्रीनाथ धाम के कपाट, विशेष पूजा होगी संपन्न उत्तराखंड: भाई दूज के पर्व पर कल सुबह बंद होंगे केदारनाथ धाम के कपाट केदारनाथ धाम: अभी तक 5 महीने में रिकॉर्ड 15 लाख यात्रियों ने किए बाबा केदार के दर्शन